Friday, July 22, 2022

COROS PACE 2, first impressions

The COROS PACE 2 was released in August 2020, and there have been many extensive reviews of it already (e.g., review 1 and review 2). So, the following are more my first impressions so far (rather than a review), what I’ve noticed the most, especially compared with my previous watch, a TomTom Spark 3 Cardio. I’ve had the Spark 3 for about three years, before switching to the PACE 2 at the end of last year.

Now I probably would have stayed with TomTom and upgraded with its newest version and not looked for alternatives, had it not decided to move away from wearables. The Spark 3 has some nice features (e.g., “fitness age”), enough for my needs. TomTom is still providing user support but apparently just until all the extant devices have aged out. The other obvious caveat, in what follows, is that I’m comparing a current PACE 2 with a 3-year-old Spark 3.

Here are my first impressions of the COROS PACE 2:


-        Top on the list is the impressively long-lasting battery!

o   My long runs so far (18-22 miles) have averaged about 10% (+/-) of battery usage for the PACE 2.

o   In comparison, the Spark 3, even when new, would not last much past a marathon, for me (~4 hrs). During its third year, the Spark 3 barely could make it past 15 miles or so. I was routinely charging it after every run, just to be sure.

o   Now, with the PACE 2, I charge it only every 2-3 weeks, depending on how much I leave it on or wear it when not running.

o   Charging is fast, just one to two hours to complete.

-        On my first run with the PACE 2, I also wore on the other arm the Spark 3 for comparison.

o   Pace and distance tracking is comparable between the two. But, the PACE 2 has more details. Also, analyses of treadmill runs are better with PACE 2.

o   Heart rate is apparently more accurate (more consistent) with the PACE 2, whereas the Spark 3 heart rate fluctuates more.

-        The PACE 2 is noticeably lighter and has a more flexible strap, compared with the Spark 3.

-        GPS acquisition is much faster than that of the Spark 3.

-        A nice, battery-saving feature: When it’s dark enough, turning one’s wrist (either side) to read the PACE 2 will prompt the watch to light up. In setup, one can specify right- or left-handed.

-        The audio at each mile is louder and the vibrate at each mile is stronger. Still, it’d be nice to be able to adjust both the tone volume and the vibrate strength. Currently, though, according to the COROS Helpdesk, neither allows for adjustment. I did provide my feedback on this to the Helpdesk, so we’ll see.

-        There’s much more analysis provided by the PACE 2 (see example below for a tempo run).


-        But, I prefer to plot against distance, not time. How to do that?

o   Clicking (obviously!) on “Distance” (lower right) does result in a plot against distance, but it showed only the average pace for each mile.

o   Not so obvious (at least to me) is the pull-down arrow (lower left), i.e., “Lap” has three options. Default is one mile. The other two are 5 miles and “Entire.” The latter should more accurately be termed “Continuous,” which is what I was looking for (see example below).

o   A nice feature of “Entire” (or “Continuous”) is that the pace for any arbitrary segment of a run (e.g., a 5K time trial from mile 2 to mile 5.1) can be easily gotten by dragging the cursor across the desired start and end distances.


o   I found out about the “Lap” pull-down arrow by contacting the COROS helpdesk, which has been super friendly and responsive!

Though the PACE 2 is at the low end of the COROS line of watches, for my needs, it has more than enough functionality. It’s easy to use. It’s incredibly affordable. And, I’m still amazed at how long the PACE 2 battery lasts!

Thursday, May 5, 2022

Multilingual warm-up

There are a couple sets of warm-up routines that I do before every run. Both of them end with front and side leg swings (15x per leg). For counting reps, sometimes I’d use English, other times Chinese. Last September, I re-started my study of Spanish that I’d begun many years ago, except now with Duolingo. So, in recent months, I’ve also used Spanish for counting reps (uno to quince and quince to uno). More recently, just for fun, I’ve tried counting in all three languages in rotating order. For example, using English->Chinese->Spanish, for right side leg kick: one, èr, tres, four, wǔ, seis, seven, bā, nueve, ten, shíyī, doce, thirteen, shísì, quince; and for left side leg kick: fifteen, shísì, trece, twelve, shíyī, diez, nine, bā, siete, six, wǔ, cuatro, three, èr, uno. (The Chinese here is pinyin, not the characters.) Different orders are more or less fluid in switching between languages. It seems, for example, Spanish->English->Chinese doesn’t flow as easily as English->Chinese->Spanish, which perhaps makes sense, i.e., the latter order is also that of my proficiency in the three languages.

Adding this fun counting to my warm-ups is great for brain training, as is language learning in general, especially as one ages. But, what does it do for running training or racing?

Perhaps it could be put to use during the latter miles of a marathon? Nah, probably not. Brain usage is too energy-intensive, and a tiring body during those last miles is already in an energy deficit. Plus, if one is already likely talking to God, is the mind going to want to count multilingually?

But, maybe in those middle miles, say 15-20 (before the real race begins), which often feel interminable, doing some mind-focused counting could help distract oneself from those complaining legs and make the miles seem to go by faster? I already do various counting routines during races and runs. This multilingual counting would be another addition to my racing mental toolkit. In recent Sunday long runs, I’ve tried it out and found it to be indeed useful-and fun!

Wednesday, March 30, 2022

Threshold mileage for running well ... and age is just a number

I had previously noted a 30-to-40-mile a week threshold during a post-injury recovery period. In the beginning of that period, as I was slowly increasing my weekly mileage, the body just felt rusty. However, once I got back above 30-40 miles a week, running felt familiar again, like seeing an old friend. But, that was just one data point.

Now I’ve a new data point for this threshold of familiarity, arising from the COVID-19 hiatus in racing. During this two-year period, I didn’t participate in any races (other than a few virtual ones, which were basically time trials), my average weekly mileage was in the 20s, and my Sunday long runs were capped at around 16 miles, with many far shorter. Overall, the body just felt sluggish and struggled over the back half of those long runs, and I’ve been thinking that perhaps the aging curve has finally caught up with the adaptation (to training) curve (!).

But, then, over the past couple months, as my 7-day moving average mileage increased to 35 and more, my long runs began to feel differently, with faster, negative-split paces. Getting to this threshold, which probably varies with the individual, is apparently what’s needed for all the loose rusty parts of my body to become lubricated and snap together to run well.

So, it is still mostly a matter of training, even at my age. 😊

And, on the subject of running and aging, an interesting story recently came from Adharanand Finn, an author, journalist, and podcaster from the U.K. (I’ve read the first two of Finn’s books: Running with the Kenyans and The Way of the Runner, both terrific reads! On my list is his third and latest book, The Rise of the Ultra Runners.) I’ve a Patreon subscription to Finn’s writings, which include a “Monday musings” article.

A “musings” article from a couple weeks ago is a story from a recent parkrun. (Here’s more information on parkruns in the U.S., still catching up in participation relative to other countries.) One of the runners who had finished ahead of Finn basically said to him afterward, wow, you’re fast … for your age. And that set Finn off on a brief thought experiment on whether thinking younger makes one feel and act younger and be perceived as such by others. So, for example, do Kenyan runners in general and Eliud Kipchoge in particular not “run their age,” because they think of themselves as younger and, thus, are not constrained by their actual chronological age?

Here's my comment on Finn’s article: ‘I’m glad that you ended not with “must accept that I’m [old]” but with “better to embrace it.” I’d say even “to celebrate it”! I don’t think the Kenyans think of themselves as younger; rather, they just don’t think much about age, as least the chronological kind, which is just a number, literally.’

And, thinking more about this, what does chronological age mean anyway, other than a counting convention for how long a mass of cells has existed relative to the number of its revolutions around the sun? Of course, there is a secular trend to aging; nothing can be done about that, though sometimes we benefit from it, e.g., aging into a BQ (😊). But, eventually, we all, well, “age out.” What’s important is how we age, and about that we can do quite a bit, to slow down aging and perhaps even reverse it to some extent (see, e.g., Arsenis et al. 2017). Biological age is far more meaningful than that chronological number. For a given chronological age, a plot of its corresponding population’s biological age would show some spread or skewness that varies with the chronological age. Most runners would probably fall on the tail somewhere of a negative skew.

Finn has also written a couple “musings” articles about Kipchoge’s chronological age, that it could very likely be well over 40 (though no one seems to know for sure)! Again, I don’t think Kipchoge simply thinks of himself as being younger, i.e., as a mental technique for training and racing; he just doesn’t think much about age. So, if Kipchoge is running as if he’s in his 30s, it’s probably because he actually is in his 30s, biologically. He’s an outlier, obviously, perhaps with good “staying young” genes. But, there is also a host of other contributing factors, as Finn has described in Running with the Kenyans and as others have as well (e.g., David Epstein’s The Sports Gene and Alex Hutchinson’s Endure).

Age really is just a number. And it is still mostly a matter of training!


Reference

Arsenis, N.C., T. You, E.F. Ogawa, G.M. Tinsley, and L. Zuo, 2017. Physical activity and telomere length: Impact of aging and potential mechanisms of action, Oncotarget, 8, 45008-45019, doi: 10.18632/oncotarget.16726.


Sunday, March 6, 2022

Another mental aspect of running

On long runs (for me, ~11 to 22 miles), how I fuel and hydrate has evolved over the years. Earlier, when my legs were younger, I would take a gel and water on the run, every 5 miles or so. Later, I would do that but while walking (0.05 to 0.15 mile), until the gel is consumed. Still later, every 5 miles became every 2.5 miles, with only water during the additional breaks (i.e., water at 2.5 mile; gel and water at 5 mile; water at 7.5 mile; etc.). More recently, I’ve been experimenting with varying distances between breaks, i.e., not every 2.5 miles. The following is my current fueling and hydrating schedule, with 0.1-mile walks while consuming the gel and water or just water. The distances run between breaks are shown in parentheses.

So, after the initial 2.8 miles, the distance run after each 0.1-mile walk decreases with each break, i.e., 2.6, 2.4, 2.3, 2.2, 2.1, 2.0, 1.9. The slightly shorter distance run after each succeeding break makes some difference, physically, but not a lot. Mentally, however, knowing that the initial 2.8-mile segment is the longest run between breaks makes the entire run seem easier. Does it result in a faster pace? Not always. Not today anyway. My 19-miler this morning was at an average pace for me nowadays. (It was unseasonably warm for early March, with the run finishing in the low 70s.)

But, the long run last Sunday (17.5 miles), with the temperature just about right, in the low 40s, was at a faster pace. It was a good run, and some of the miles were like “running on water.” 😊 Also, once I had run a faster-than-usual, easy mile, what felt easy though fast, for subsequent miles, persisted. Several times, I was pleasantly surprised when I checked the watch.

The mental aspects of running are so fascinating.

 

Monday, January 24, 2022

Marathon courses, fast and slow

What makes a marathon course fast or slow? Profile or grade is one factor, for sure. The Pocono Mountains Run for the Red Marathon has one of the most runner-friendly profiles.

At the other end of the profile spectrum, the Grandfather Mountain Marathon is, as its website states, “One of America’s Toughest Marathons.”

There are many compilations of fastest marathon courses. The following table of marathons I have run is a subset of those in the original table in one such compilation, FindMyMarathon (accessed 1/17/2022), that ranked 495 marathons from fastest to slowest (so far, all in the U.S. and Canada). It was purely a coincidence that the races I’ve run covered the entire range of the original table. 

The rankings are periodically updated. When I’d checked it in early fall of 2021, the Pocono Mountains Run for the Red Marathon was still on the list. But then in October, the race organizers decided to discontinue the race, in part because of the pandemic. I kept it in the table below, because Pocono was where I ran my marathon PR (3:55) in 2016 and qualified for the Boston Marathon for the first time. It was ranked the 26th fastest course before being discontinued.

The marathons are ranked using each race's Personal Record (PR) Score. The PR Score is derived from an algorithm based on the effects of three factors on running performance: grade (G), elevation (E), and temperature (T). There’s also a related ranking using each race’s Course Score (G+E, no T). Column 1 of the table below shows the ranking based on all three factors (and the most recent year I’d run it), whereas column 2 shows the ranking based on the Course Score. The BQ % is the percentage of runners who qualified for the Boston Marathon according to the latest race results. As can be seen, the BQ % does not directly indicate a fast or slow course.

Grade (G), Elevation (E), Temperature (T); NA - Not available

Rank (G+E+T)

Rank (G+E)

Month, location (elevation in ft)

Race name

PR score

BQ %

Grade

1 (Did not run)

1

April, Las Vegas, NV (2030)

REVEL Mt. Charleston

107.03

NA

Downhill

(2019)

26

May, Stroudsburg PA, (2215)

Pocono Mountains Run for the Red

101.36

8.52%

Downhill

48 (2018)

57

October, Corning, NY (932)

Wineglass

99.76

17.71%

Downhill

54 (2014)

73

March, Virginia Beach, VA (13)

Shamrock

99.68

3.24%

Very flat

156 (2019)

206

November, Harrisburg, PA (351)

Harrisburg

99.07

18.26%

Mostly flat

247 (2013)

310

October, Wash., DC (72)

Marine Corps

98.47

NA

Mostly flat

324 (2012)

379

October, Baltimore, MD (240)

Baltimore

97.72

4.04%

Hilly

344 (2017)

397

April, Gettysburg, PA (538)

Gettysburg North-South

97.53

14.39%

Rolling

430 (2018)

101

September, Wash., DC (72)

Abebe Bikila Day International Peace

95.58

15.63%

Mostly flat

494 (2013)

491

July, Boone, NC (5946)

Grandfather Mountain

84.80

NA

Very hilly

495 (Did not run)

495

October, Breckenridge, CO (9600)

Breckenridge Road

83.98

0.10%

Hilly


Notes:
- An assumption of the rankings is that pre-race training has been optimal.
- I did not run #1 and #495; these two fastest and slowest courses, respectively, are included for reference.
- For most courses, G+E+T and G+E rankings don’t differ by enough to change the relative rankings.
- One noticeable exception is the Abebe Bikila Day International Peace Marathon along the Potomac River in Washington, DC. It ranks 101 if only grade and elevation are considered, but 430 if temperature is also included (!). This Potomac race is scheduled in early September to enable any Boston Qualifying results to be submitted within the qualifying window for the following year’s Boston Marathon. But that means the race is typically run with a mean temperature in the 70s (F)--plus the swampy humidity!
- Only for the Grandfather Mountain Marathon is the elevation (at 5946 ft.) possibly a factor. As elevation increases, of course, it becomes more and more a factor. Of all the races I’ve run, not just marathons, the one at the highest elevation was Copper Mountain Half Marathon at 9600 ft. That definitely was a factor!

Beyond grade, elevation, and temperature, there are other factors that could speed up or slow down a course, e.g.,

- Time of year/weather (other than temperature): rain, humidity, wind speed/direction.
- Number of turns in the course.
- Race field size: some optimal size between not too crowded to impede (e.g., Marine Corps Marathon in 2013) and not too sparse to become uncompetitive (i.e., more like a time trial).
- Availability and quality of pacers.
- Spectator size and distribution.

While the latter factors, which are mental rather than physical, help make the running easier and thus the course faster, other mental factors can make the running easier though not necessarily faster. For example, last summer, on a warm August morning, I did the following 15-mile "intestinal" run.


One "lap" is ~13.8 miles, so a marathon would be shorter than two laps. Which is interesting, because, mentally, that seems easier than a typical marathon route. Now I did run it slowly, because it was a hilly route, I was pacing by target heart rate, and it was a warm August morning. But I think it's more than just the slow pace. At the farthest, the route is less than two miles from home. So, I know well every street, cul-de-sac, many of the houses, signs on their fences, dogs to wave at (and those to avoid), churches, schools, etc. That familiarity, along with the more visual chunking (e.g., cul-de-sac) allowing the route to be run and focused on one chunk at a time, I think is what made the mental effort easier--though the course was a slow one.

Friday, December 31, 2021

A running review of 2021

It was not a year of running I had expected. After vaccinations began in spring, I thought an actual in-person race would be possible in the latter months of the year, perhaps the Walnut Creek Half in California that I almost always run in December. In May, I got so optimistic that I signed up for the Parks Half Marathon in Maryland. But Delta came along, so I decided to transfer my registration to 2022. Omicron then followed. In-person races were being held, of course, including those big-city marathons, with various modifications due to COVID. And, as far as I know, no big outbreaks of infections have resulted. But, running an in-person race is not an absolute necessity; I can wait.

Aside from races, my running almost returned to the pre-pandemic schedule norm for periods in between races. Two small adjustments were carrying a mask, just in case, and occasionally crossing the street to socially distance. Total mileage was 1365, not bad for a no-race and, thus, no-training year. Here are some highlights from 2021:

1. Most memorable run, in freezing rain, during which my eyesight got progressively worse--until I realized that both sides of my glasses were iced over.

2. See-if-I-could-do-it run, at the local high school track, where I ran 50+ laps (13 mi) to get a sense of the mental aspect of such running. Or racing. Not quite Self-Transcendence 3100 or a 24-hour run. But, it was good to know that 50+ laps was not a problem—and certainly easier than on a treadmill!

3. Most aural run, on the way to Las Trampas Elderberry Trailhead near San Ramon, CA. It was my Sunday long run, and I underestimated the distance by about two miles. But, I was glad the 14-mile out-and-back run became 18 miles. Else, I'd have missed the bovine choir (with a canine guest solo)!


4. New #Runmymindmap project: T. rex. Following are the challenge, the plan, and the best result so far (6th try). T. rex was harder than the NASA meatball, in part because the resolution of my GPS watch was limiting (e.g., for T. rex's eye).


As we count down towards 2022, remember, “it’s not inevitable”! Stay safe, stay healthy, keep running!













 

Sunday, April 18, 2021

Run, minimally

Several years ago, a colleague of mine gave a Goddard colloquium talk on Giovanni (an online visualization and analysis system for NASA satellite data). In discussing the system's workflow engine, he said one of the requirements for the engine is that it runs minimally (i.e., does only that which is absolutely necessary). Naturally, I immediately thought of minimalist running, that it's not just about shoes but also (more so?) about running efficiency--doing only that which is absolutely necessary.

But, let’s stay with shoes for now. Here’s Google Trends for 2004-present for the four indicated search terms. Annotations are of events that I knew or googled that plausibly explain some of the trends.

Following are some notes and links corresponding to the above trends and annotations.

[1] McDougall, Christopher, 2009. Born to run: A hidden tribe,superathletes, and the greatest race the world has never seen, featuring Tarahumara runners in sandals. Publication of this book led to a peak interest in barefoot running over the next 2-3 years.

[2] Hoka One One, the beginning of a slow but steadily rising interest in maximalist shoes (backlash to minimalist shoes?).

[3] Minimalist shoes sale boom, with a small lag following the publication of Born to Run (min_1; min_2); these two articles are just to reference the “sales up 303%” in the Google Trends chart above.

 [4] Kipchoge ran his unofficial sub-2 marathon in Vaporfly, as did Brigid Kosgei in breaking Paula Radcliffe’s 16-year-old marathon world record, which, along with many other records and PRs being set left and right, put the spotlight on a shoe that’s been already out there for a couple years.

[5] Vaporfly approval by World Athletics and what led to the review and ruling.

[6] New Vaporfly releases

It’s almost like, at some point between the releases of the Hokas and Vaporflys, someone thought, hmm, that’s a lot of space in those soles just for cushioning … (1, 2). But, even before Vaporfly, the basic idea already existed, e.g., various you-gotta-be-kidding-me spring-loaded shoes.

With the advantage these spring-contraption shoes provides, is there an “asterisk” problem for elite runners? Evidently, yes, for now anyway. For example, last month, Chris Thompson qualified for the marathon event of the upcoming delayed 2020 Summer Olympics, after winning the 2021 British Athletics Marathon--wearing a blacked-out pair of Vaporfly. Why blacked out? Because his shoe sponsor doesn’t make Vaporfly. (He did have his sponsor’s permission to wear the Vaporfly, though—if blacked out.) Then, a couple weeks later, Beth Potter broke the world record for 5K while wearing shoes similar to Vaporfly but made by Asics. (Her WR may not be official, though, because there were no “certified timekeepers or drug testers on site.”) Apparently responding to questions about her shoes, Potter said, “But all athletes now have access to the same level of shoes, so it’s a level playing field.”

But, if everyone has to wear these shoes (blacked-out or not) to be competitive, then it's basically everyone normalizing to a faster base speed. The competition reverts to what it was before these shoes, plus perhaps a small competitive delta based on who can get more or less out of the claimed 4% improvement. What's the point, then? Other than Nike and other companies making lots of money.

And, for the rest of us, there’s a similar asterisk problem. What does “I ran a new 4% PR!” mean, if done with a 4%-improvement Vaporfly? As with age-grading, is there going to be shoe-grading, to account for runners who will be racing with and without these shoes? :)

Regardless of the pros and cons of these various types of shoes (or no shoes), I’m a minimalist runner. I run, minimally. My transition from traditional running shoes to minimalist shoes began some 10 years ago and took more than a year. First was Nike Free, then followed by Merrell’s Trail Glove, Bare Access, and Vapor Glove, Vibram FiveFingers, and occasionally sandals and barefoot. Below left is my first pair of Trail Glove (still the all-time favorite!), and below right is the latest pair of FiveFingers (lightest of them all, except for barefoot; great for traveling!)


Running is more, much more, than speed, PRs, or even WRs. Too much focus on speed and technology misses the meaning of running. It’s certainly not why I run. Now, one might say, well, yes, but competition brings out the best. Exactly. 😊 In the runner, not shoes.

Run free at any speed.